Hayes
Hayes v. 2831 Ellendale Place, Inc.
Opinion
Lead Opinion
Wood, J.
The complaint alleges that defendant corporation became indebted to plaintiff Stephen Hayes for building construction services rendered at the special request of defendant, in the reasonable value of $7,500, and that no part thereof has been paid.
The eighth alleged affirmative defense is that the alleged cause of action is barred by the statute of limitations, section 339, subdivision 1, of the Code of Civil Procedure (i.e., action on oral contract barred within two years).
Pursuant to section 597 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and upon motion of defendant, the issue as to the statute of limitations was tried first. The court determined that the cause of action was barred by said provision of the statute of limitations. Plaintiff appeals from the judgment.
Plaintiff, a licensed contractor, testified that: Between October 1, 1957, and June 1, 1958, he acted as the general building contractor in constructing, for defendant, a 24-unit apartment building at 2831 Ellendale Place in Los Angeles. That the reasonable value of the labor performed and materials used in constructing the building (including the demolition of an old building) was $75,149.48. He did not render any service…