Kuebler

San Diego Humane Society v. Kuebler

Good Law
233 Cal. App. 2d 341
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaMarch 30, 1965Civ. No. 7609California2,724 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Coughlin, J.

Lucy T. Beckley executed her will on February 18, 1959. She died about two years later, i.e., on March 31, 1961. Thereafter her will was admitted to probate. The chief beneficiaries under prior wills, i.e., San Diego Humane Society, a corporation, and The San Diego Society for Crippled Children, a corporation, filed a petition seeking revocation of probate upon the grounds that at the time of the execution of her will (1) she was of unsound mind and (2) acted under undue influence. At the close of contestants ’ case the court granted a motion for nonsuit on the issue of undue influence as to one of the proponents. After both sides concluded their cases the court granted proponents’ motion for a directed verdict. Judgment denying revocation of probate was entered accordingly. The contestants appeal from the judgment and the order of nonsuit.

The primary issue for determination by this court is whether there is substantial evidence in support of either ground of contest, i.e., (1) that at the time of the execution of the will Mrs. Beckley was of unsound mind, or (2) that in executing the same she acted under undue influence.

The rules of law applicable to such a situation are well…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.