Haskins

Haskins v. Holmes

Good Law
1967 Cal. App. LEXIS 1540·252 Cal. App. 2d 580·60 Cal. Rptr. 659
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaJuly 14, 1967Civ. No. 31590California2,813 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Lillie, J.

Plaintiff sued for damages ($100,000 general, $25,000 punitive, costs incurred for medical care, loss of wages and costs of suit) for personal injuries arising out of an assault and battery. The cause was tried to the court sitting without a jury. The facts as they appear in the findings show that on December 13, 1963, defendant struck, assaulted and attacked plaintiff causing severe personal injuries to his head and face requiring medical care and surgical attention. Judgment was entered in favor of plaintiff against defendant for $1,000. Plaintiff’s motion for new trial on the ground that as a matter of law the damages awarded were grossly inadequate was denied; he appeals from the judgment.

The appeal is on the clerk’s transcript. In the material outside of the formal judgment roll in the record are all exhibits introduced into evidence at the trial—group of photographs (Exh. 1); hospital (Exh. 2), anesthesiology (Exh. 3) and doctor (Exh. 4) bills; surgical report (Exh. 5) ; letter from Dr. Shapiro dated June 8, 1964 (Exh. 6); St. Francis Hospital records (Exh. 7); certified copies of municipal court minutes (Exh. A) and copy of police report (Exh. B). Inasmuch as there is…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.