Chung
People v. Chung
Opinion
Lead Opinion
Klein, J.
Keith Chung was charged by information with two counts of cruelty to an animal and possession of a controlled substance. (Pen. Code, *724 § 597, subd. (a); Health & Saf. Code, § 11350, subd. (a).) 1 Prior to trial, Chung moved to suppress evidence seized during a search of his residence on the theory the police lacked exigent circumstances justifying warrantless entry.
The trial court conducted a hearing on the motion. Chung’s neighbor, Jennifer Lee, testified she called the police in the early morning hours of July 13, 2007, and reported hearing the high-pitched crying of a dog in pain in the unit above hers. Lee told the officers who responded to her call that she had heard similar sounds in the past, but this time it sounded more serious. The officers went to Chung’s door but he said he did not own any dogs. While the officers spoke to Chung, one of them heard the faint sound of a dog whimpering inside Chung’s condominium. Believing there was an animal in distress, the officers entered without a warrant after Chung refused the officers permission to enter.
The officers found an injured dog on the patio and a dead dog in the freezer section of the refrigerator. The…