Sporn
Vitatech Int'l, Inc. v. Sporn
Opinion
lead Opinion
Aronson, J.
*800 Seeking more than $166,000 in damages, plaintiff Vitatech International, Inc. (Vitatech) filed this breach of contract lawsuit against defendants National Marketing, Inc., CortiSlim International, formerly known as National Marketing, Inc., CortiSlim International, LLC, and Alan R. Sporn (collectively, Defendants). On the eve of trial, the parties settled for a one-time payment of $75,000. As part of the settlement, Defendants stipulated to entry of judgment against them "in the full prayer of the Complaint," but Vitatech agreed to "forbear" from filing the stipulation and to accept the $75,000 "as full Settlement of its claims against Defendants" if they paid by the designated date. When Defendants failed to pay, Vitatech filed the stipulation and the trial court entered judgment against Defendants for more than $300,000, which included compensatory damages, prejudgment interest, attorney fees, and costs.
Sporn and appellant CortiSlim International, Inc. (collectively, Appellants) moved to vacate the judgment, arguing it was an unenforceable penalty and under Civil Code section 1671, subdivision (b) ( section 1671(b) ). The trial court denied the motion because it found the…