Lowe

Lowe v. McDonald

Good Law
15 Alaska 510·221 F.2d 228
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitApril 11, 1955No. 14153California1,342 words

Opinion

lead Opinion

Driver, J.

In March, 1947, Evelyn Mahan executed a lease, covering certain mining claims in the Fairbanks, Alaska area, to James McDonald. In association with Charles Creavey and' James H. Pierce, he mined the claims under the lease until August, 1948, when the operation was discontinued. Mrs.. Mahan died in February, 1950, leaving a will which named Grace Lowe, as executrix and sole legatee. In February, 1953, Grace Lowe, as executrix and “sole heir” of the estate of Evelyn Mahan, commenced the present action in the District Court against McDonald and his associates. Five causes of action were alleged in the complaint. A trial before the court without a jury resulted in judgment for the defendants and the present appeal followed.

The fifth cause of action has been expressly abandoned and need not be considered further. The third and fourth causes of action, which present the question whether the trial court erred in taking judicial notice of a prior action between the same parties in the same court will be discussed later on in this opinion. The first cause of action was for unpaid royalty under the lease from Mrs. Mahan to McDonald. The lease required the lessee to pay a minimum of.…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.