Swan
Swan v. First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston
Opinion
Lead Opinion
Pope, J.
This is an appeal from a decision finally dismissing, with prejudice, two counts of appellant’s complaint and granting a summary judgment upon the remaining third count. Appellees moved to dismiss the appeal on the ground that the court below lacked jurisdiction for want of the required diversity of citizenship, and hence that we may not entertain the appeal.
If there be federal jurisdiction here, it is dependent on diversity of citizenship. Plaintiff-appellant is a citizen of California. Each of the named defendants is alleged to be “a juridical entity, duly organized, existing, recognized and regarded as a body corporate under and by virtue of the laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.” The named Church, Board of Directors and Publishing. Society, describing themselves respectively as “an unincorporated religious trusteeship or society”, as a “group of individuals who are the trustees” for such society, and as “a trusteeship” moved in the trial court to dismiss the action for want of jurisdiction, the same ground now urged for dismissal of the appeal. The trial court held the objection to jurisdiction not well taken, but dismissed the first two counts for failure to state a…