Robertson

Carpenters Health & Welfare Trust Funds v. Robertson

Good Law
53 F.3d 1064
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitMay 8, 1995No. 93-16098California2,293 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Reinhardt, J.

Section 1113(f) of the bankruptcy code limits the power of a bankrupt company to unilaterally terminate or modify the terms of a collective bargaining agreement. Some courts have found that this provision also affects the priority accorded debts payable under a collective bargaining agreement in the bankruptcy priority scheme. In this case, we decide whether § 1113(f) applies to bankruptcies filed under Chapter 7 of the Code. We hold that it does not.

BACKGROUND

Rufener Construction Co. filed a Chapter 7 bankruptcy petition. Over the following two months, the Operating Engineers Trust Funds and the Carpenters Trust Funds (hereinafter “Trust Funds”) filed separate claims against the estate totaling almost $75,-000. The claims were for employee benefit contributions payable under collective bargaining agreements. The agreements required contributions to employee benefit trust funds on the basis of hours of work performed. The Trust Funds sought payment for work performed prior to the bankruptcy filing and asserted priority status for the claims. The Trustee objected. During discovery, the Trustee learned that the claim of priority status was based on § 1113(f) of the Code rather…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.