Columbia Steel Casting Co. v. Portland General Electric Co.

ORDER

The Petition for Rehearing, filed August 3, 1995, is hereby GRANTED.

The Opinion filed July 20, 1995, and reported at 60 F.3d 1390 , 1396 (9th Cir.1995), is WITHDRAWN and the attached Opinion is ordered filed instead.

OPINION

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. Facts and Procedural History...............................................1452

II. State-Action Immunity................. 1455

A. The Mideal Clear Articulation Requirement...............................1455

B. Issue Preclusion......................................................1460

C. Foreseeability: PGE’s New Argument on Appeal..........................1461

III. PGE’s Other Defenses.................. 1463

A. Statute of Limitations:.................................................1463

B. Justification Defenses..........................-........................1464

C. The Noerr-Pennington Doctrine........................................1464

D. The Filed Rate Doctrine...............................................1465

IV. Damages.................................................................1465

V. Columbia Steel’s Cross-Appeal on Damages----'..............................1466

VI.…