45 Fed. R. Evid. Serv. 1143, 96 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 8007, 96 Daily Journal D.A.R. 13,300 Johanna Trevino v. Daryl Gates Tom Bradley Tom Reddin Roger Murdock Ed Davis Herbert Boeckmann James Fisk Stephen Gavin Maxwell Greenberg Elbert Hudson Marguerite Justice Emmett McGaughey Salvador Montenegro Barbara Schlei Robert Talcott Reva Tooley Robert Weil Samuel Williams Stephen Yslas Lapd Officers Jerry Brooks Joseph Callian Warren Sirk Richard Spellman Gary Strickland James Tippings Richard Zierenberg Manuel Avila Charles Bennett Brian Davis John Fruge Joseph Freia E.T. Guiza Peter Sanchez Reginald Weaver James Toma C.S. Winston Philip Wixon Gary Zerbey Joel Wachs Joy Picus John Ferraro Zev Yaroslavsky Ruth Galanter Ernani Bernardi Nate Holden Marvin Braude Hal Bernson Michael Woo Joan Flores One Hundred Unknown Named Employees or Officials of the City of Los Angeles, All in Both Their Individual and Official Capacities City of Los Angeles, Johanna Trevino v. Daryl F. Gates, Chief of Police Tom Bradley Tom Reddin Roger Murdock Ed Davis Herbert Boeckmann James Fisk Stephen Gavin Maxwell Greenberg Elbert Hudson Marguerite Justice Emmett McGaughey Salvador Montenegro Barbara L. Schlei Robert Talcott Reva B. Tooley Robert Weil Samuel L. Williams Stephen D. Yslas Jerry Brooks Joseph Callian Warren Eggar David B. Harrison John Helms Michael Sirk Richard Spellman Gary Strickland James Tippings Richard Zierenberg Manuel Avila Charles Bennett Brian Davis John Fruge Joseph Freia E.T. Guiza Peter Sanchez Reginald Weaver James Toma C.S. Winston Philip Wixon Gary Zerbey Joel Wachs Joy Picus John Ferraro Zev Yaroslavsky Ruth Galanter Ernani Bernardi Nate Holden Marvin Braude Hal Bernson Michael Woo Joan Milke Flores One Hundred Unknown Named Employees/officials of the City of Los Angeles, All in Both Their Individual and Official Capacities City of Los Angeles

Good Law

99 F.3d 911

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitNovember 1, 199695-55290California7,512 words

Opinion

99 F.3d 911 45 Fed. R. Evid. Serv. 1143 , 96 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 8007, 96 Daily Journal D.A.R. 13 ,300 Johanna TREVINO, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Daryl GATES; Tom Bradley; Tom Reddin; Roger Murdock; Ed Davis; Herbert Boeckmann; James Fisk; Stephen Gavin; Maxwell Greenberg; Elbert Hudson; Marguerite Justice; Emmett McGaughey; Salvador Montenegro; Barbara Schlei; Robert Talcott; Reva Tooley; Robert Weil; Samuel Williams; Stephen Yslas; LAPD Officers; Jerry Brooks; Joseph Callian; Warren Sirk; Richard Spellman; Gary Strickland; James Tippings; Richard Zierenberg; Manuel Avila; Charles Bennett; Brian Davis; John Fruge; Joseph Freia; E.T. Guiza; Peter Sanchez; Reginald Weaver; James Toma; C.S. Winston; Philip Wixon; Gary Zerbey; Joel Wachs; Joy Picus; John Ferraro; Zev Yaroslavsky; Ruth Galanter; Ernani Bernardi; Nate Holden; Marvin Braude; Hal Bernson; Michael Woo; Joan Flores; One Hundred Unknown Named Employees or Officials of the City of Los Angeles, all in both their individual and official capacities; City of Los Angeles, Defendants-Appellees. Johanna TREVINO, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Daryl F. GATES, Chief of Police; Tom Bradley; Tom Reddin; Roger Murdock; Ed Davis; Herbert…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.

Parties

45 Fed. R. Evid. Serv. 1143, 96 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 8007, 96 Daily Journal D.A.R. 13,300 Johanna Trevino
Plaintiff
Daryl Gates Tom Bradley Tom Reddin Roger Murdock Ed Davis Herbert Boeckmann James Fisk Stephen Gavin Maxwell Greenberg Elbert Hudson Marguerite Justice Emmett McGaughey Salvador Montenegro Barbara Schlei Robert Talcott Reva Tooley Robert Weil Samuel Williams Stephen Yslas Lapd Officers Jerry Brooks Joseph Callian Warren Sirk Richard Spellman Gary Strickland James Tippings Richard Zierenberg Manuel Avila Charles Bennett Brian Davis John Fruge Joseph Freia E.T. Guiza Peter Sanchez Reginald Weaver James Toma C.S. Winston Philip Wixon Gary Zerbey Joel Wachs Joy Picus John Ferraro Zev Yaroslavsky Ruth Galanter Ernani Bernardi Nate Holden Marvin Braude Hal Bernson Michael Woo Joan Flores One Hundred Unknown Named Employees or Officials of the City of Los Angeles, All in Both Their Individual and Official Capacities City of Los Angeles, Johanna Trevino v. Daryl F. Gates, Chief of Police Tom Bradley Tom Reddin Roger Murdock Ed Davis Herbert Boeckmann James Fisk Stephen Gavin Maxwell Greenberg Elbert Hudson Marguerite Justice Emmett McGaughey Salvador Montenegro Barbara L. Schlei Robert Talcott Reva B. Tooley Robert Weil Samuel L. Williams Stephen D. Yslas Jerry Brooks Joseph Callian Warren Eggar David B. Harrison John Helms Michael Sirk Richard Spellman Gary Strickland James Tippings Richard Zierenberg Manuel Avila Charles Bennett Brian Davis John Fruge Joseph Freia E.T. Guiza Peter Sanchez Reginald Weaver James Toma C.S. Winston Philip Wixon Gary Zerbey Joel Wachs Joy Picus John Ferraro Zev Yaroslavsky Ruth Galanter Ernani Bernardi Nate Holden Marvin Braude Hal Bernson Michael Woo Joan Milke Flores One Hundred Unknown Named Employees/officials of the City of Los Angeles, All in Both Their Individual and Official Capacities City of Los Angeles
Defendant

Cites (59)

99 F.3d 911
96 D.A.R. 13
804 F. Supp. 69
50 F.3d 1502
58 F.3d 439
134 L. Ed. 2d 209
988 F.2d 868
9 F.3d 1433
79 F.3d 115
7 F.3d 1405
896 F.2d 398
538 F. Supp. 770
573 F. Supp. 1375
27 F.3d 1432
915 F.2d 1367
445 U.S. 622
979 F.2d 1342
637 F.2d 1350
480 U.S. 257
436 U.S. 658
728 F.2d 762
477 U.S. 317
946 F.2d 630
485 U.S. 112
859 F.2d 797
47 F.3d 1522
81 F.3d 881
56 F.3d 1138
435 U.S. 247
477 U.S. 299
973 F.2d 706
792 F.2d 915
922 F.2d 1426
824 F.2d 768
727 F.2d 202
10 F.3d 1505
773 F.2d 1068
118 L. Ed. 2d 424
499 U.S. 1
818 F.2d 1411
947 F.2d 1418
732 F.2d 693
56 F.3d 1128
133 L. Ed. 2d 336
703 F.2d 1136
837 F.2d 1461
947 F.2d 374
73 F.3d 895
488 F.2d 714
526 F.2d 67
48 L. Ed. 2d 195
976 F.2d 1536
67 F.3d 248
465 U.S. 886
997 F.2d 857
32 F.3d 1415
475 U.S. 469
794 F.2d 534
932 F.2d 795