96 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 9203, 97 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 1350, 96 Daily Journal D.A.R. 15,215, 97 Daily Journal D.A.R. 2025 James Senator Marks Tommy Marks David Marks v. John R. Clarke William F. Grub Stephen W. Keane Michael Lavelle Gerald R. Poindexter Robert Vanleuven Ralph C. Weir, James Senator Marks Tommy Marks David Marks, Gypsy Church of the Northwest v. John R. Clarke William F. Grub Stephen W. Keane Michael Lavelle Gerald R. Poindexter Robert Vanleuven Ralph C. Weir, and Robert G. Bailor Denise E. Coker Monte E. Gaunt Donald E. Johnson Richard J. Poole Nicolis E. Stanley Michael F. Yates, James Senator Marks Tommy Marks David Marks v. John R. Clarke William F. Grub Stephen W. Keane Michael Lavelle Gerald R. Poindexter Robert Vanleuven Ralph C. Weir, and City of Spokane Robert Allen Earl L. Ennis Lawrence R. Freeman Clifford Harding Kenneth R. Krogh Larry M. Lindskog Jack E. Neumiller Andrew J. Pavlischak Sheldon Reeve, Gypsy Church of the Northwest v. Spokane County, and John R. Clarke William F. Grub Stephen W. Keane Michael Lavelle Gerald R. Poindexter Robert Vanleuven Ralph C. Weir, Gypsy Church of the Northwest v. Spokane County, and Robert G. Bailor Denise E. Coker Monte E. Gaunt Donald E. Johnson Richard J. Poole Nicolis E. Stanley Michael F. Yates, Gypsy Church of the Northwest v. Spokane County, and City of Spokane Robert Allen Earl L. Ennis Lawrence R. Freeman Clifford Harding Kenneth R. Krogh Larry M. Lindskog Jack E. Neumiller Andrew J. Pavlischak Sheldon Reeve, Gypsy Church of the Northwest, and Grover Marks v. Detective Rick Grabenstein

Good Law

102 F.3d 1012

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitFebruary 26, 199718-15292California15,024 words

Opinion

102 F.3d 1012 96 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 9203 , 97 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 1350, 96 Daily Journal D.A.R. 15 ,215, 97 Daily Journal D.A.R. 2025 James Senator MARKS; Tommy Marks; David Marks, Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. John R. CLARKE; William F. Grub; Stephen W. Keane; Michael Lavelle; Gerald R. Poindexter; Robert VanLeuven; Ralph C. Weir, Defendants-Appellants, James Senator MARKS; Tommy Marks; David Marks, Gypsy Church of the Northwest, Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. John R. CLARKE; William F. Grub; Stephen W. Keane; Michael Lavelle; Gerald R. Poindexter; Robert VanLeuven; Ralph C. Weir, Defendants, and Robert G. Bailor; Denise E. Coker; Monte E. Gaunt; Donald E. Johnson; Richard J. Poole; Nicolis E. Stanley; Michael F. Yates, Defendants-Appellants. James Senator MARKS; Tommy Marks; David Marks, Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. John R. CLARKE; William F. Grub; Stephen W. Keane; Michael Lavelle; Gerald R. Poindexter; Robert VanLeuven; Ralph C. Weir, Defendants, and City of Spokane; Robert Allen; Earl L. Ennis; Lawrence R. Freeman; Clifford Harding; Kenneth R. Krogh; Larry M. Lindskog; Jack E. Neumiller; Andrew J. Pavlischak; Sheldon Reeve, Defendants-Appellants. GYPSY CHURCH OF THE NORTHWEST,…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.

Parties

96 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 9203, 97 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 1350, 96 Daily Journal D.A.R. 15,215, 97 Daily Journal D.A.R. 2025 James Senator Marks Tommy Marks David Marks
Plaintiff
John R. Clarke William F. Grub Stephen W. Keane Michael Lavelle Gerald R. Poindexter Robert Vanleuven Ralph C. Weir, James Senator Marks Tommy Marks David Marks, Gypsy Church of the Northwest v. John R. Clarke William F. Grub Stephen W. Keane Michael Lavelle Gerald R. Poindexter Robert Vanleuven Ralph C. Weir, and Robert G. Bailor Denise E. Coker Monte E. Gaunt Donald E. Johnson Richard J. Poole Nicolis E. Stanley Michael F. Yates, James Senator Marks Tommy Marks David Marks v. John R. Clarke William F. Grub Stephen W. Keane Michael Lavelle Gerald R. Poindexter Robert Vanleuven Ralph C. Weir, and City of Spokane Robert Allen Earl L. Ennis Lawrence R. Freeman Clifford Harding Kenneth R. Krogh Larry M. Lindskog Jack E. Neumiller Andrew J. Pavlischak Sheldon Reeve, Gypsy Church of the Northwest v. Spokane County, and John R. Clarke William F. Grub Stephen W. Keane Michael Lavelle Gerald R. Poindexter Robert Vanleuven Ralph C. Weir, Gypsy Church of the Northwest v. Spokane County, and Robert G. Bailor Denise E. Coker Monte E. Gaunt Donald E. Johnson Richard J. Poole Nicolis E. Stanley Michael F. Yates, Gypsy Church of the Northwest v. Spokane County, and City of Spokane Robert Allen Earl L. Ennis Lawrence R. Freeman Clifford Harding Kenneth R. Krogh Larry M. Lindskog Jack E. Neumiller Andrew J. Pavlischak Sheldon Reeve, Gypsy Church of the Northwest, and Grover Marks v. Detective Rick Grabenstein
Defendant

Cites (44)

102 F.3d 1012
960 F.2d 104
472 U.S. 511
514 U.S. 35
114 Wash. 2d 724
116 S. Ct. 1769
988 F.2d 868
76 F.3d 1032
58 F.3d 439
134 L. Ed. 2d 209
475 U.S. 335
444 U.S. 1049
41 F.3d 1306
457 U.S. 800
58 F.3d 423
444 U.S. 85
468 U.S. 897
859 F.2d 667
777 F.2d 1376
803 F.2d 1042
60 N.J. 319
20 Wash. App. 535
37 Wash. App. 94
718 F.2d 332
783 F.2d 1371
706 F.2d 1000
677 F.2d 1336
800 F.2d 959
452 U.S. 692
35 F.3d 680
131 L. Ed. 2d 554
791 F.2d 1329
446 U.S. 754
958 F.2d 332
870 F.2d 1335
116 S. Ct. 834
999 F.2d 417
968 F.2d 865
115 S. Ct. 2151
75 F.3d 1090
21 F.3d 826
933 F.2d 748
759 F.2d 1486
88 L. Ed. 2d 119