German

Physician's Surrogacy, Inc. v. German

Good Law
311 F. Supp. 3d 1190
United States District Court, Southern District of CaliforniaApril 19, 2018Case No.: 17cv718–MMA (WVG)California1,885 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

If recovery of attorney's fees is limited to prevailing plaintiffs under California Penal Code § 502(e), Defendants are not permitted to recover their attorneys' fees as Defendants. See Swearingen , 2010 WL 1495204 , at *2 ; Facebook, Inc. , 2017 WL 3394754 , at *6 ; OptiStreams, Inc. , 2006 WL 829113 , at *10. If the decision to award fees remains within the trial court's discretion, the Court finds it would be unreasonable to award fees because the Court did not determine that Plaintiff's section 502 claim was either frivolous or abusive. See U.S. Source LLC , 2014 WL 6977597 , at *4 ; see Doc. No. 49 at 20-21 (declining to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over Plaintiff's state law claims, but stating that "[i]f Plaintiff sufficiently alleges a federal claim in a future amended complaint, the Court will reconsider exercising supplemental jurisdiction over Plaintiff's state law claims"). Accordingly, the Court declines to award Defendants attorneys' fees under section 502(e).

3. The DTSA

Plaintiff also contends Defendants are not entitled to attorneys' fees under the DTSA because they are not the prevailing party and Plaintiff's DTSA claim was not made in bad faith. Oppo. at…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.