In Re: The Exxon Valdez, Grant Baker, as Representatives of the Mandatory Punitive Damages Class v. Joseph Hazelwood, and Exxon Corporation Exxon Shipping Company, in Re: The Exxon Valdez, Grant Baker, as Representatives of the Mandatory Punitive Damages Class v. Exxon Corporation Exxon Shipping Company, and Joseph Hazelwood, Daniel R. Calhoun Bradford J. Chisholm David P. Clarke Thomas S. McAllister Phillip G. McCrudden Michael J. McClenaghan Guy Piercey Hugh Wisner Grant C. Baker Larry L. Dooley Kim J. Ewers John W. Herschleb Kent Herschleb David B. Horne Michael J. Owecke Gerald E. Thorne George A. Gordaoff Old Harbor Native Corporation Timberline, Inc. Barbara Brown John Foges Jamie L. Halladay Charles McMahon Jennifer Briggs Terri Mast Mark T. Coles Fred Galicano Mike Hollerbeke Kathy Bryan Vincent Libed Art Huddleston Opinion Robert Love Roxane Villaueva Marcelo Rombaoa Scott Hulbert Brian Gillis Frank Michael Carlson Elenor McMullen Native Village of Larsen Bay Native Village of Chenega Bay v. Exxon Corporation Exxon Shipping Company Joseph Hazelwood

Good Law

270 F.3d 1215

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitNovember 7, 200197-35191California19,991 words

Opinion

270 F.3d 1215 (9th Cir. 2001) IN RE: THE EXXON VALDEZ, GRANT BAKER, ET AL., AS REPRESENTATIVES OF THE MANDATORY PUNITIVE DAMAGES CLASS, PLAINTIFFS-APPELLEES v. JOSEPH HAZELWOOD, DEFENDANT, AND EXXON CORPORATION; EXXON SHIPPING COMPANY, DEFENDANTS-APPELLANTS IN RE: THE EXXON VALDEZ, GRANT BAKER, ET AL., AS REPRESENTATIVES OF THE MANDATORY PUNITIVE DAMAGES CLASS, PLAINTIFFS-APPELLEES, v. EXXON CORPORATION; EXXON SHIPPING COMPANY, DEFENDANTS, AND JOSEPH HAZELWOOD, DEFENDANT-APPELLANT DANIEL R. CALHOUN; BRADFORD J. CHISHOLM; DAVID P. CLARKE; THOMAS S. MCALLISTER; PHILLIP G. MCCRUDDEN; MICHAEL J. MCCLENAGHAN; GUY PIERCEY; HUGH WISNER; GRANT C. BAKER; LARRY L. DOOLEY; KIM J. EWERS; JOHN W. HERSCHLEB; KENT HERSCHLEB; DAVID B. HORNE; MICHAEL J. OWECKE; GERALD E. THORNE; GEORGE A. GORDAOFF; OLD HARBOR NATIVE CORPORATION; TIMBERLINE, INC.; BARBARA BROWN; JOHN FOGES; JAMIE L. HALLADAY; CHARLES MCMAHON; JENNIFER BRIGGS; TERRI MAST; MARK T. COLES; FRED GALICANO; MIKE HOLLERBEKE; KATHY BRYAN; VINCENT LIBED; ART HUDDLESTON; OPINION ROBERT LOVE; ROXANE VILLAUEVA; MARCELO ROMBAOA; SCOTT HULBERT; BRIAN GILLIS; FRANK MICHAEL CARLSON; ELENOR MCMULLEN; NATIVE VILLAGE OF LARSEN BAY; NATIVE VILLAGE OF…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.

Parties

In Re: The Exxon Valdez, Grant Baker
Plaintiff
Joseph Hazelwood, and Exxon Corporation Exxon Shipping Company, in Re: The Exxon Valdez, Grant Baker
Defendant

Cites (100)

270 F.3d 1215
25 F.3d 773
121 S. Ct. 1678
997 F.2d 1244
30 F.3d 1077
769 F.2d 1426
239 F.3d 985
229 F.3d 790
206 F.3d 900
121 F.3d 503
120 F.3d 166
104 F.3d 1196
102 F.3d 429
101 F.3d 86
74 F.3d 373
34 F.3d 769
959 F.2d 805
35 F. Supp. 2d 756
952 F. Supp. 9
952 F. Supp. 455
142 F.R.D. 380
767 F. Supp. 1509
991 P.2d 769
991 P.2d 757
946 P.2d 875
866 P.2d 827
962 P.2d 196
16 U.S. 546
234 F.3d 58
121 F.3d 1421
70 F.3d 694
767 F.2d 1379
59 F.3d 1496
369 U.S. 527
498 U.S. 19
3 Cai. Cas. 175
209 F.2d 178
7 F.3d 1464
244 N.Y. 84
59 F.3d 953
453 U.S. 1
451 U.S. 304
730 F.2d 835
459 U.S. 375
455 U.S. 745
441 U.S. 418
385 U.S. 276
512 U.S. 415
499 U.S. 1
Id.
527 U.S. 526
136 F. 577
191 F.3d 1010
977 F.2d 1347
872 F.2d 642
407 F.2d 1143
585 F. Supp. 1062
967 F.2d 322
761 F.2d 1363
180 F.3d 997
212 F.3d 477
494 U.S. 545
477 U.S. 242
693 F.2d 932
684 F.2d 658
431 F.2d 584
13 F.3d 1357
122 F.3d 820
517 U.S. 559
108 F.3d 1123
192 F.3d 902
139 F.3d 1241
418 U.S. 323
13 How. 363
509 U.S. 443
463 U.S. 277
33 F.3d 1116
103 F.3d 767
737 F. Supp. 1099
215 F.3d 1052
813 F.2d 1394
95 F.3d 1422
19 F.3d 677
204 F.3d 920
923 F.2d 1371
656 F.2d 469
878 F.2d 1200
656 F.2d 1147
275 U.S. 303
501 F.2d 558
510 U.S. 443
516 U.S. 199
244 U.S. 205
32 F.3d 623
900 F. Supp. 697
786 F. Supp. 853
365 U.S. 731
362 U.S. 440
411 U.S. 325
21 P.3d 344