Planned Parenthood of the Columbia/willamette, Inc. Portland Feminist Women's Health Center Robert Crist, M.D. Warren M. Hern, M.D. Elizabeth Newhall, M.D. James Newhall, M.D., and Karen Sweigert, M.D. v. American Coalition of Life Activists Advocates for Life Ministries Michael Bray Andrew Burnett David A. Crane Timothy Paul Dreste Michael B. Dodds Joseph L. Foreman Charles Roy McMillan Stephen P. Mears Bruce Evan Murch Catherine Ramey Dawn Marie Stover Charles Wysong, and Monica Migliorino Miller Donald Treshman, Planned Parenthood of the Columbia/willamette, Inc. Portland Feminist Women's Health Center Robert Crist, M.D. Warren M. Hern, M.D. Elizabeth Newhall, M.D. James Newhall, M.D., and Karen Sweigert, M.D. v. American Coalition of Life Activists Advocates for Life Ministries Michael Bray Andrew Burnett David A. Crane Timothy Paul Dreste Joseph L. Foreman Stephen P. Mears Monica Migliorino Miller Catherine Ramey Dawn Marie Stover Donald Treshman Charles Wysong, and Michael Dodds Charles Roy McMillan Bruce Evan Murch, Planned Parenthood of the Columbia/willamette, Inc. Portland Feminist Women's Health Center Robert Crist, M.D. Warren M. Hern, M.D. Elizabeth Newhall, M.D. James Newhall, M.D., and Karen Sweigert, M.D. v. American Coalition of Life Activists Advocates for Life Ministries Michael Bray Andrew Burnett David A. Crane Michael Dodds Charles Roy McMillan Stephen P. Mears Monica Migliorino Miller Bruce Evan Murch Catherine Ramey Dawn Marie Stover Donald Treshman, and Timothy Paul Dreste Joseph L. Foreman Charles Wysong, Planned Parenthood of the Columbia/willamette, Inc. Portland Feminist Women's Health Center Robert Crist, M.D. Warren M. Hern, M.D. Elizabeth Newhall, M.D. James Newhall, M.D., and Karen Sweigert, M.D. v. American Coalition of Life Activists Advocates for Life Ministries Michael Bray Andrew Burnett David A. Crane Catherine Ramey Dawn Marie Stover, and Timothy Paul Dreste Michael Dodds Joseph L. Foreman Charles Roy McMillan Stephen P. Mears Monica Migliorino Miller Bruce Evan Murch Donald Treshman Charles Wysong, Planned Parenthood of the Columbia/willamette, Inc. Portland Feminist Women's Health Center Robert Crist, M.D. Warren M. Hern, M.D. Elizabeth Newhall, M.D. James Newhall, M.D. v. American Coalition of Life Activists Advocates for Life Ministries Michael Bray Andrew Burnett David A. Crane Timothy Paul Dreste Michael B. Dodds Joseph L. Foreman Charles Roy McMillan Bruce Evan Murch Catherine Ramey Dawn Marie Stover Donald Treshman Charles Wysong, Paul Deparrie, Movant-Appellant. Planned Parenthood of the Columbia/willamette, Inc. Portland Feminist Women's Health Center Robert Crist, M.D. Warren M. Hern, M.D. Elizabeth Newhall, M.D. James Newhall, M.D. Karen Sweigert, M.D., Individually and on Behalf of All Persons Similarly Situated v. American Coalition of Life Activists Advocates for Life Ministries Michael Bray Andrew Burnett David Crane Timothy Paul Dreste Michael Dodds Joseph L. Foreman Charles Roy McMillan Monica Migliorino Miller Bruce Evan Murch Catherine Ramey Dawn Marie Stover Donald Treshman Charles Wysong

Bad Law
290 F.3d 1058
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitJuly 10, 200299-35325California38,009 words

Opinion

Opinion

290 F.3d 1058 PLANNED PARENTHOOD OF THE COLUMBIA/WILLAMETTE, INC.; Portland Feminist Women's Health Center; Robert Crist, M.D.; Warren M. Hern, M.D.; Elizabeth Newhall, M.D.; James Newhall, M.D., Plaintiffs-Appellees, and Karen Sweigert, M.D., Plaintiff, v. AMERICAN COALITION OF LIFE ACTIVISTS; Advocates for Life Ministries; Michael Bray; Andrew Burnett; David A. Crane; Timothy Paul Dreste; Michael B. Dodds; Joseph L. Foreman; Charles Roy McMillan; Stephen P. Mears; Bruce Evan Murch; Catherine Ramey; Dawn Marie Stover; Charles Wysong, Defendants, and Monica Migliorino Miller; Donald Treshman, Defendants-Appellants. Planned Parenthood of the Columbia/Willamette, Inc.; Portland Feminist Women's Health Center; Robert Crist, M.D.; Warren M. Hern, M.D.; Elizabeth Newhall, M.D.; James Newhall, M.D., Plaintiffs-Appellees, and Karen Sweigert, M.D., Plaintiff, v. American Coalition of Life Activists; Advocates for Life Ministries; Michael Bray; Andrew Burnett; David A. Crane; Timothy Paul Dreste; Joseph L. Foreman; Stephen P. Mears; Monica Migliorino Miller; Catherine Ramey; Dawn Marie Stover; Donald Treshman; Charles Wysong, Defendants, and Michael Dodds; Charles Roy McMillan; Bruce Evan…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.