Defenders of Wildlife Center for Biological Diversity Craig Miller v. United States Environmental Protection Agency, National Association of Home Builders State of Arizona Arizona Chamber of Commerce, Intervenors. Defenders of Wildlife Center for Biological Diversity, Plaintiffs-Petitioners v. Robert B. Flowers, Chief of Engineers and Commander, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers., Defendant-Respondent, Christine Todd Whitman, Administrator U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Defendant-Respondent, Gale Norton Steven Williams, Defendants-Respondents, Continental Reserve Ii, Llc, Defendant-Intervenor/intervenor, Hb Land Development Company Stephen A. Owens, State of Arizona, Ex-Rel, Director Arizona Department of Environmental Quality Grosvenor Holdings National Association of Home Builders Home Builders Association of Central Arizona Southern Arizona Home Builders Association Saguaro Ranch Investments LLC Saguaro Ranch Development Corporation, Defendant-Intervenors/intervenors

Caution

420 F.3d 946·35 Envtl. L. Rep. (Envtl. Law Inst.) 20172·60 ERC (BNA) 2025·2005 U.S. App. LEXIS 17983

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitAugust 22, 200503-71439California18,544 words

Opinion

420 F.3d 946 DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE; Center for Biological Diversity; Craig Miller, Petitioners, v. UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, Respondent, National Association of Home Builders; State of Arizona; Arizona Chamber of Commerce, Intervenors. Defenders of Wildlife; Center for Biological Diversity, Plaintiffs-Petitioners, v. Robert B. Flowers, Chief of Engineers and Commander, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers., Defendant-Respondent, Christine Todd Whitman, Administrator U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Defendant-Respondent, Gale Norton; Steven Williams, Defendants-Respondents, Continental Reserve II, LLC, Defendant-Intervenor/Intervenor, HB Land Development Company; Stephen A. Owens, State of Arizona, ex-rel, Director Arizona Department of Environmental Quality; Grosvenor Holdings; National Association of Home Builders; Home Builders Association of Central Arizona; Southern Arizona Home Builders Association; Saguaro Ranch Investments LLC; Saguaro Ranch Development Corporation, Defendant-Intervenors/Intervenors. No. 03-71439. No. 03-72894. United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. Argued and Submitted November 1, 2004. Filed August 22, 2005. COPYRIGHT MATERIAL…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.

Parties

Defenders of Wildlife Center for Biological Diversity Craig Miller
Plaintiff
United States Environmental Protection Agency, National Association of Home Builders State of Arizona Arizona Chamber of Commerce, Intervenors. Defenders of Wildlife Center for Biological Diversity- v. Robert B. Flowers, Chief of Engineers and Commander, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.-, Christine Todd Whitman, Administrator U.S. Environmental Protection Agency-, Gale Norton Steven Williams-, Continental Reserve Ii, Llc-Intervenor/intervenor, Hb Land Development Company Stephen A. Owens, State of Arizona, Ex-Rel, Director Arizona Department of Environmental Quality Grosvenor Holdings National Association of Home Builders Home Builders Association of Central Arizona Southern Arizona Home Builders Association Saguaro Ranch Investments LLC Saguaro Ranch Development Corporation-Intervenors/intervenors
Defendant

Cites (41)

420 F.3d 946
437 U.S. 153
520 U.S. 154
468 U.S. 737
504 U.S. 555
230 F.3d 1141
528 U.S. 167
313 F.3d 1094
35 F.3d 1300
541 U.S. 752
236 F.3d 1124
150 F.3d 1072
158 F.3d 491
341 F.3d 961
48 F.3d 1495
414 F.3d 1066
463 U.S. 29
273 F.3d 1229
490 U.S. 360
898 F.2d 1410
137 F.3d 291
318 U.S. 80
540 U.S. 644
529 F.2d 359
413 F.3d 1024
532 U.S. 200
83 F.3d 1068
65 F.3d 1502
340 F.3d 969
50 F.3d 677
962 F.2d 27
515 U.S. 687
204 F.3d 920
289 F.3d 89
23 F.3d 1508
490 U.S. 477
75 F.3d 541
556 F.2d 1282
784 F.2d 959
201 F.3d 1186
467 U.S. 837