No. 04-15306

477 F.3d 1048 Earl F. ARAKAKI; Evelyn C. Arakaki; Edward U. Bugarin; Sandra P. Burgess; Patricia A. Carroll; Robert M. Chapman; Michael Y. Garcia; Toby M. Kravet; James I. Kuroiwa; Frances M. Nichols; Donna Malia Scaff; Jack H. Scaff; Allen Teshima; Thurston Twigg-Smith, Plaintiffs-Appellants, Anthony Sang, Sr., State Council of Hawaiian Homestead Associations (SCHHA); State Council of Hawaiian Homestead Associations, Intervenors-Appellees, v. Linda C. LINGLE, in her official capacity as Governor of the State of Hawaii; Haunani Apoliona, Chairman, and in her official capacity as trustee of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs; Rowena Akana, in his official capacity as trustee of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs; Donald Cataluna, in his official capacity as trustee of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs; Linda Dela Cruz, in her official capacity as trustee of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs; Clayton Hee, in his official capacity as trustee of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs; Colette Y. Machado, in her official capacity as trustee of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs; Charles Ota, in his official capacity as trustee of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs; Oswald K. Stender, in his official capacity as…