Marrama
Marrama v. Citizens Bank
Opinion
Lead Opinion
Stevens, J.
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The principal purpose of the Bankruptcy Code is to grant a “ ‘fresh start’ ” to the “ ‘honest but unfortunate debtor.’ ” Grogan v. Garner, 498 U.S. 279, 286, 287 , 111 S.Ct. 654 , 112 L.Ed.2d 755 (1991). Both Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 of the Code permit an insolvent individual to discharge certain unpaid debts toward that end. Chapter 7 authorizes a discharge of prepetition debts following the liquidation of the debtor’s assets by a bankruptcy trustee, who then distributes the proceeds to creditors. Chapter 13 authorizes an individual with regular income to obtain a discharge after the successful completion of a payment plan approved by the bankruptcy court. Under Chapter 7 the debt- or’s non-exempt assets are controlled by the bankruptcy trustee; under Chapter 13 the debtor retains possession of his property. A proceeding that is commenced under Chapter 7 may be converted to a Chapter 13 proceeding and vice versa. 11 U.S.C. §§ 706 (a), 1307(a) and (c).
An issue that has arisen with disturbing frequency is whether a debtor who acts in bad faith prior to, or in the course of, filing a Chapter 13 petition by, for example, fraudulently concealing…
Dissenting Opinion
Alito, J.
dissenting.
Under the clear terms of the Bankruptcy Code, a debtor who initially files a petition under Chapter 7 has the right to convert the case to another chapter under which the case is eligible to proceed. The Court, however, holds that a debtor’s conversion right is conditioned upon a bankruptcy judge’s finding of “good faith.” Because the imposition of this condition is inconsistent with the Bankruptcy Code, I respectfully dissent.
I
The Bankruptcy Code unambiguously provides that a debtor who has filed a bankruptcy petition under Chapter 7 has a broad right to convert the ease to another chapter. Title 11 § 706(a) states:
*1113 The Code restricts a Chapter 7 debtor’s conversion right in two — and only two— ways. First, § 706(a) makes clear that the right to convert is available only once: A debtor may convert so long as “the case has not been converted [to Chapter 7] under section 1112, 1208, or 1307 of this title.” Second, § 706(d) provides that a debtor wishing to convert to another chapter must meet the conditions that are needed in order to “be a debtor under such chapter.” Nothing in § 706(a) or any other provision of the Code suggests that a bankruptcy judge has…