Warren

Warren v. Fox Family Worldwide, Inc.

Bad Law
328 F.3d 1136·2003 WL 21058184
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitMay 13, 2003No. 01-57107California3,793 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Hawkins, J.

In this dispute between plaintiff-appellant Richard Warren (‘Warren”) and defendants-appellees Fox Family Worldwide (“Fox”), MTM Productions (“MTM”), 1 Princess Cruise Lines (“Princess”), and the Christian Broadcasting Network (“CBN”), Warren claims that defendants infringed the copyrights in musical compositions he created for use in the television series “Remington Steele.” Concluding that Warren has no standing to sue for infringement because he is neither the legal nor beneficial owner of the copyrights in question, we affirm the district court’s Rule 12 dismissal of Warren’s complaint.

FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

Warren and Triplet Music Enterprises, Inc. (“Triplet”) entered into the first of a series of detailed written contracts with MTM concerning the composition of music for “Remington Steele.” This agreement stated that Warren, as sole shareholder and employee of Triplet, would provide services by creating music in return for compensation from MTM. Under the agreement, MTM was to make a written accounting of all sales of broadcast rights to the series and was required to pay Warren a percentage of all sales of broadcast rights to the series made to third parties not…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.