Montgomery v. Kirkwood Development, Inc.

Good Law
122 F. App'x 872
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitNovember 23, 2004No. 03-55104; Nos. 03-56696, 03-56697, 03-56702, 04-55357; BAP Nos. CC-02-01611-PB, CC-02-01610-MoLK, CC-02-01611-MoLK, CC-03-01395-MoLK, CC-03-01395-MaKMoCalifornia803 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

MEMORANDUM **

Charles Montgomery and Kirkwood Development, Inc., appeal the Bankruptcy Appellate Panel’s decision which, for the most part, affirmed the bankruptcy court’s determination that a purchase money deed of trust in favor of United International Mortgage and Investment, Inc., had priority over their judgment liens. They also appeal various other issues. We agree with the BAP and affirm the bankruptcy court in part, but vacate in part on account of mootness.

(1) The bankruptcy court did not err when it determined that United had priority. Under California law, purchase money deeds of trust have priority over general judgment liens previously filed against a debtor. See Cal. Civ.Code § 2898(a); Van Loben Sels v. Bunnell, 120 Cal. 680, 683-84 , 53 P. 266, 267 (1898); Walley v. P.M.C. Inv. Co., Inc., 262 Cal. App.2d 218, 220 , 68 Cal.Rptr. 711 , 712—13 (1968); Mercantile Collection Bureau v. Roach, 195 Cal.App.2d 355, 357-58 , 15 Cal. Rptr. 710, 711-12 (1961). It is apparent that United was a purchase money lender. 1 Even if there is a “good faith” requirement before a purchase money lien has priority, that is satisfied when, as here, the lender did advance the money and…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.