Pastor
Pastor v. Kennedy CA4/1
Opinion
Opinion
INTRODUCTION
A former member of a limited liability company appeals from a judgment on the
pleadings in a damages action after the trial court granted motions in limine excluding
evidence of liability and damages because the member sold his interest in the company in
a separate, related dissolution action. We conclude the trial court properly determined
the final resolution of the dissolution action deprived the member of standing to maintain any derivative claims and the doctrine of election of remedies barred the member from
maintaining any individual claims in the damages action. We, therefore, affirm the
judgment.
BACKGROUND
Damages Action
In June 2008 Robert Pastor filed a lawsuit against John Kennedy seeking damages
and injunctive relief. The operative second amended complaint (complaint) asserted
causes of action for fraud and deceit, breach of fiduciary duties, breach of contract, and
intentional interference with prospective economic advantage.
General Allegations
The complaint generally alleged, in 2005 and January 2006, Pastor worked for
J. Kelly Construction Supply (J. Kelly), a business of Kennedy's that imported and
distributed stone and stone…