P.
P. v. Lopez CA4/2
Opinion
Opinion
DISCUSSION
During trial, defendant requested a foundation hearing as to the introduction of his
statements to Sergeant Mooney, claiming a Miranda violation. After the jury was
excused, Sergeant Mooney testified that prior to interviewing defendant, he read
2 The taped interview was played for the jury, and a transcription of the interview was admitted into evidence.
3 defendant his Miranda rights from a card; and that defendant had agreed to speak with
him. The following colloquy occurred between defendant and Sergeant Mooney:
“MOONEY: Having these rights in mind, do you, will you talk to me and answer
some questions I have —
“[DEFENDANT]: Well —
“MOONEY: — of you?
“[DEFENDANT]: No.
“MOONEY: You don’t want to talk to me?
“[DEFENDANT]: No, uh, what did you say?
“MOONEY: I said having those rights in mind –
“[DEFENDANT]: Oh, Okay . . .
“MOONEY: Understanding those rights, will you talk to me if, if I, about, answer
some questions I have?
“[DEFENDANT]: Yeah.”
In response to defense counsel’s question, “But we just heard the tape and
[defendant] did say ‘No,’” Sergeant Mooney explained, “He—he looked like he was—
didn’t fully understand, and so that is why I…