Covilland
United States v. Covilland
Opinion
Lead Opinion
Hoffman, J.
By the decree of the board of commissioners, there was confirmed to the claimants a tract of land of the extent of seven leagues, of which the boundaries were given. A survey having been made of the quantity confirmed, within the exterior boundaries, (which were found to embrace a much larger extent of land), it was, on objections made to the secretary of the interior, set aside, and a new survey made pursuant to his instructions. This last survey has been returned into court, under the provisions of the act of 1860 [ 12 Stat. 33 ]. ■ It is an admitted rule, not only of this court, but of the executive department of the government, that, in locating a given quantity of land granted to a claimant within exterior boundaries containing a much larger quantity, the claimant has the right of election as to the land to be surveyed. The election so to be exercised must be reasonable, nor must it be unnecessarily injurious to the adjacent public lands of the United States. If, by the acts of the grantee, such as occupying and cultivating a portion of the land, or selling parts of it to third persons, the election appears to have already been made, he will be estopped to make a new…