Semple

United States v. Semple

Good Law
27 F. Cas. 1019·1860 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 14
United States District Court, Northern District of CaliforniaSeptember 1, 1860California1,642 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Hoffman, J.

The counsel for the claimant [C. D. Semple] in this moves for an order approving a survey made by the surveyor in pursuance of an order heretofore entered, rejecting the original survey, and giving directions for a new and reformed survey to be made. Before proceeding to inquire whether the last survey is in conformity with the directions heretofore given, a preliminary question must be determined.

By the recent act of congress (June 14, 1860), “all cases in which proceedings are pending for the purpose of contesting or reforming surveys made and approved by the surveyor-general, are made subject to the provisions of the act.” If, then, in this case, such proceedings are pending, the provisions of the act must be applied to it. To determine whether proceedings are pending within the meaning of the act, the nature of the order or decree heretofore made must be considered. If that decree be a final decree, the case can no longer be said to be pending, and vice versa. It is obvious that, in'a large majority of cases, no decree by which one sur- ' vey is rejected, and another directed to be made, can be deemed a final decr.ee. The directions contained in such a decree must usually be…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.