McGraw

McGraw v. States S. S. Co.

Good Law
116 F. Supp. 446·1953 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 2243
United States District Court, Northern District of CaliforniaNovember 25, 1953No. 26355California461 words

Opinion

lead Opinion

Harris, J.

Libelant seeks maintenance and cure from respondent. The cause of action arises out of an illness suffered by libel-ant while on board respondent’s vessel on a voyage to the Far East.

Respondent, by way of defense, relies upon a release of all claims and demands executed by libelant upon receipt of $600.

Respondent has. the. burden .of showing that the seaman acted freely and with a full understanding of his fights when he signed the release in consideration of the moneys paid him. Garrett v. Moore-McCormack, 317 U.S. 239 , 63 S.Ct. 246 , 87 L.Ed. 239 .

The evidence at the trial establishes the fact that libelant took the initiative in suggesting a settlement. In the light of the known medical history at the time, there was no overreaching on respondent’s part. Libelant McGraw, himself, obtained the abstract of the clinical - record from the Marine Hospital which showed that the libelant was *447 then suffering from painless gross hematuria — etiology unknown. This record was further substantiated by the report from the Bluff Hospital, Yokohama, . Japan, which was known to both parties.

On February 21, 1952, based on the Marine Hospital report and that of the Bluff Hospital,…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.