Moats

New York Life Ins. v. Moats

Good Law
125 C.C.A. 143·207 F. 481·1913 U.S. App. LEXIS 1638
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitAugust 4, 1913No. 2,228California5,617 words

Opinion

lead Opinion

Morrow, J.

(after stating the facts as above). The defendant denies its liability on the two'insurance policies for $5,000 each, issued to the plaintiffs as beneficiaries, on the life of George S. Moats, on two grounds:

(1) It is charged in defendant’s answer that at the time of making application for such insurance, George S. Moats, the insured, made false and fraudulent answers and representations to two certain questions asked him by Dr. H. L. Underwood, the medical examiner of the insurance company, such answers and representations being material to the risk, and known to be false and fraudulent by both the insured and the beneficiaries. The two questions and answers charged to have been false and fraudulent were preceded by the following general question:

If either of these answers was false and fraudulent, it may be assumed that the insurance company had no knowledge of their false and fraudulent character at the time of the delivery of the policies of insurance, and that the answers were material to' the risk.

(2) It is also alleged in defendant’s answer that the policies ox insurance were not to take effect until delivery to the applicant; that subsequent to making application for…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.