Noe G.

Good Law
148 C.C.A. 613·235 F. 119·1916 U.S. App. LEXIS 2182
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitAugust 7, 1916No. 2689California292 words

Opinion

lead Opinion

Ross, J.

This case arose out of a collision between two gasoline power boats, one named Noe G. and the other E’Etruria. At the time of the collision and for some time prior thereto there was a heavy fog prevailing, and the two boats were approaching each other practically dead ahead.

The court below found as facts that the lookout on E’Etruria sighted the Noe G. when the two boats were from 40 to 50 feet apart, whereupon the helm of E’Etruria was at once ported and she went to starboard; that the Noe G. did not sight E’Etruria until 10 to 15 feet from her, and that, had the lookout on the Noe G. been properly placed and attending to his duties, he could have seen L’Etruria when she was at least from 40 to 50 feet distant; that, after sighting L’Etru *120 ria, the Noe G. held her course and struck L’Etruria on her port bow just forward of the chain plates, breaking a large hole in that boat, through which the sea entered so rapidly that within a few minutes she sank, with a consequent loss of $2,500—no damage resulting to the Noe G.

The court having further found that E’Etruria, although running in a heavy fog, had not prior to the collision been blowing her fog horn, accordingly found…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.