Wonderland Nurserygoods Co Ltd v. Baby Trend, Inc.

Case 5:14-cv-01153-JWH-SP Document 412 Filed 02/13/ Page 1 of Page ID #:26937

O

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

WONDERLAND NURSERYGOODS Case No. 5:14-cv-01153-JWH-SP

CO., LTD.,

Plaintiff, MEMORANDUM OPINION AND

ORDER ON PLAINTIFF’S

v. MOTION FOR PARTIAL

SUMMARY JUDGMENT [ECF

BABY TREND, INC., No. 310], DEFENDANT’S DENNY TSAI, and MOTION FOR SUMMARY BETTY TSAI, JUDGMENT [ECF Nos. 307 & 326], and DEFENDANT’S DAUBERT Defendants. MOTION [ECF No. 367] Case 5:14-cv-01153-JWH-SP Document 412 Filed 02/13/ Page 2 of Page ID #:26938

I. SUMMARY OF DECISION

Presently before the Court in this patent infringement case are three motions: • Plaintiff Wonderland NurseryGoods Co., Ltd. moves for summary judgment of infringement against Defendant Baby Trend, Inc. with respect to Baby Trend’s Category 1 products;1 • Baby Trend moves for summary judgment of non-infringement, invalidity, and intervening rights;2 and • Baby Trend moves to exclude and strike certain rebuttal opinions by Bryan Van Uden, Wonderland’s…