Marcos Vega v. City Loan Holdings LLC

CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA JS-

CIVIL MINUTES - GENERAL

Case No. CV 23-7203 MRW Date November 14, 2023 Title Vega v. City Loan Holdings

Present: Hon. Michael R. Wilner, U.S. Magistrate Judge James Muñoz n/a Deputy Clerk Court Reporter / Recorder Attorneys for Plaintiff: Attorneys for Defendant: n/a n/a Proceedings: ORDER REMANDING ACTION TO STATE COURT 1. The Court held a hearing on Plaintiffs’ motion to remand this action to the state superior court. (Docket # 10, 27.) As stated at the hearing, it’s likely that diversity of citizenship jurisdiction actually exists in this action. However, the Comvest defendants acknowledge that – for reasons made clear in their papers – they have affirmatively withheld key information about some of their members. 2. The Court concludes that, as a factual matter, the defense has not adequately proved the citizenship of all of the parties in the action. As a result, this federal court does not have jurisdiction over the case. Because the defense wishes to maintain this “data status quo,”…