Pacific Packaging Concepts, Inc. v. Nutrisystem, Inc.
Opinion
Trial Court Opinion
O
44 55 66 77 United States District Court 88 Central District of California 99 1100 1111 PACIFIC PACKAGING CONCEPTS, Case No. 2:19-cv-04755-ODW (Ex)
INC.,
1122 ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND Plaintiff, DENYING IN PART DEFENDANTS’ 1133 MOTION FOR PARTIAL v. SUMMARY JUDGMENT [51] 1144 NUTRISYSTEM, INC, et al., 1155 Defendants. 1166
1177 1188 I. INTRODUCTION 1199 Plaintiff Pacific Packaging Concepts, Inc. initiated this action against 2200 Nutrisystem, Inc. and Nutri/System IPHC, Inc. (collectively, “Nutrisystem”) for 2211 trademark infringement because Nutrisystem marketed and sold products using 2222 Pacific Packaging’s “Fresh Start” mark. (Compl., ECF No. 1.) Pending before the 2233 Court is Nutrisystem’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, which is fully briefed. 2244 (MPSJ, ECF Nos. 51, 55-1; Opp’n, ECF No. 83; Reply, ECF No. 81.) For the reasons 2255 discussed below, the Court GRANTS IN PART AND DENIES IN PART 2266 Nutrisystem’s Motion.1 2277
2288 1 Having carefully considered the…