Browning
Browning v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.
Opinion
Trial Court Opinion
I. BACKGROUND
26 While Plaintiffs expect an automatic transmission to “start, accelerate, decelerate, and stop 27 erratically, causing numerous safety concerns.” FAC ¶ 9. In 2014, AHM began equipping select 1 vehicle models with a 9-speed “automatic” transmission designed to increase fuel economy. Id. ¶ 3. Plaintiffs allege that the improved fuel economy came at a “significant and undisclosed cost: rough and delayed shifting, loud noises during shifting, harsh engagement of gears, sudden, harsh 5 accelerations and decelerations, and sudden loss of power.” Id. 6 According to Plaintiffs, traditional automatic transmissions use a set of gears that provide a 7 given number of ratios. FAC ¶ 8. The transmission shifts between gears to provide the most 8 appropriate ratio for a given situation. Id. According to Plaintiffs, that normally means the 9 transmission will automatically shift into lower gears for starting, middle gears for acceleration and passing, and higher gears for more fuel-efficient cruising. Id. The ZF 9HP Automatic Transmission allegedly differs from traditional automatic transmissions in that it uses a 9.8 ratio 13 spread, as opposed to 6,…