In re Joshua Lemarr Treadwell

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 6 TRINITY FINANCIAL SERVICES, LLC, Case No. 23-cv-00490-PCP

Creditor-Appellant,

ORDER AFFIRMING DENIAL OF

v. MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM

JUDGMENT AND IMPOSITION OF

JOSHUA LEMARR TREADWELL, DISCOVERY SANCTIONS Debtor-Appellee.

12 This is an appeal from a bankruptcy court decision denying relief under Rule 60(b) from an order in the case of Debtor-Appellee Joshua Lemarr Treadwell. After Creditor-Appellant Trinity Financial Services, LLC did not respond to a motion by Mr. Treadwell to value real property that he owned, the bankruptcy court entered an order which had the effect of eliminating Trinity’s lien on the property. Trinity sought relief under Rule 60(b), claiming it had not received notice of the motion. Mr. Treadwell opposed Trinity’s motion. After a hearing, several rounds of briefing, and a trial, the bankruptcy court denied Trinity’s motion and also imposed $13,265 in related discovery sanctions. Trinity now appeals this decision…