Carmichael
Carmichael v. County of San Diego
Opinion
Trial Court Opinion
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 10 KIRK MATTHEW CARMICHAEL, Case No.: 19-cv-01750-GPC-AGS ROBERT E. BASKIN on behalf of
STARS IN THE SKY TRUST, ORDER GRANTING MOTIONS TO
DISMISS WITHOUT PREJUDICE. Plaintiffs,
14 v. ECF Nos. 4, 6, 10.
COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO, PETER
ESTES, SUMMER STEPHAN,
MICHAEL HOLMES, JOHN STALEY,
AUTONATION DBA BMW OF
ENCINITAS, TOYOTA OF
ESCONDIDO, AND DOES 1-
19 inclusive, 20 Defendant.
22 Plaintiffs Kirk Matthew Carmichael (“Plaintiff”) and Robert E. Baskin (“Trustee”) 23 (collectively, “Plaintiffs”), on behalf of the Stars in the Sky Trust (“Trust”), have filed a 24 complaint alleging a wide variety of constitutional and statutory violations against the 25 Defendants County of San Diego, Peters Esters, Summer Stephan, Michael Holmes, John 26 Staley, AutoNation DBA BMW of Encinitas, Toyota of Escondido, and multiple Doe 27 individuals. ECF No. 1. Three of these Defendants – John Staley, Michael Holmes, and the County of San Diego…