Outlaw Laboratory, LP v. DG in PB, LLC
Opinion
Trial Court Opinion
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 10 IN RE: OUTLAW LABORATORIES, LP Case No.: 18CV840 GPC (BGS)
LITIGATION,
ORDER DENYING EX PARTE
. APPLICATION TO QUASH
SUBPOENA TO JOSEPH VALERIO
15 [ECF 277] 16 17 Third-Party Defendant Tauler Smith has filed an Ex Parte Application to Quash Subpoena to Joseph Valerio (“the Motion”). (ECF 277.) Counter-claimant Roma Mikha and Third-Party Plaintiff NMRM, Inc. and Skyline Market, Inc. (collectively the “Stores”) have filed an Opposition. (ECF 279.) For the reasons set forth below, the Application is DENIED. /// ///
26 1 The Court set a deadline for the Stores to file an Opposition. (ECF 278.) The Court did not provide for the filing of a reply by Tauler Smith and Tauler Smith did not seek leave 28 I. BACKGROUND Following the submission of letter briefs to the Court raising numerous discovery disputes, the Court granted the Stores’ request to serve a document subpoena on Mr. Valerio after the close of discovery. (ECF 266 ¶ 3.2) The…